Random Thought: Liu, Dead or Alive?

6 min read

Deviation Actions

Jinbeizamezama's avatar
Published:
1.7K Views
ケケケー
怒ってるかい~? おまえ~?
~~~

Dead.

Definitely dead.

BUT Before I go into my analysis of why he is dead; I want to add something to my last Random Thought analysis thingy on Slenders and Shinigami (gingaakam.deviantart.com/journ… )

I stated that "I'm not sure if a human can become a slender; as I'm pretty sure slenders are born, not made from a transition.   " BUT I had forgotten all about Sexual Offenderman (Sorry Smexy) and how he was once a human who was turned into a slender by Splendorman. And I was talking with someone on this topic as well. So it seems that the ways that slenders reproduce is either from breeding or slenders turning humans into slenders. However it seems that there are less female slenders than male slenders, which would reduce the likelihood of reproducing that way, and not all of them want to have kids. And there are probably only a few slenders who know the secret to making a human a slender, because if they all knew there would be a lot more slenders and that would just be not good; not that slenders aren't good, just that too much is not always better. Splendy is the one who turned Smexy into a slender, which means that he knows the secret. Thank Zalgo he knows moderation. I'm guessing Slenderman knows because he seems to be the most knowledgeable and wise out of all of them.
On this topic of slenders reproducing, I had another random thought: could you imagine Zehnder as a father? XD The kid would be all "DADDY DADDY I ALMOST DIED THIS GUY HAD A SHOTGUN AND SHOT ME!" and runs up to Zehnder with a huge hole in his torso. Zehnder looks up from the magazine he's reading or something for a split second, "Man the f-ck up." and then goes back to reading. (but later he'll go out and kill every person within a 20 mile radius who owns a shotgun)

Anywho, back to the topic at hand; Liu is dead. Dead with it.

No but seriously, here's the short of it (completely forgot how that expression went): With Jeff's personality portrayed in his story, there's a very very very very very very -deep inhale- very very very very very small possibility that he would have spared his brother. 

Here's the long version:
In Jeff's story he obviously cared for his brother and parents alike, like any normal kid would do. However, after his mental snap, he was obviously not a normal kid anymore; saying things like his new burned and bleached face 'fits my new personality perfectly!' (or something like that, too lazy to go back and grab the actual quote [also, HINT HINT, NEW PERSONALITY if the bold didn't give it to you.]), burning his own eyelids off his face (gotta admit that takes a combination of guts and an insane mind to do), and carving his own face.
And then after that he kills his parents he goes off to kill his brother with the bloodied knife, giving him the iconic phrase of 'Go To Sleep', and I highly doubt that he meant 'Just go to sleep little bro, not gonna do anything with this huge ass bloody knife I promise. Tomorrow we can go chase butterflies in the meadow again.'
With his 'new personality' he obviously killed or attempted to kill his brother. And he had obviously been successful with the murder of his parents, two grown adults, I highly doubt that a boy of around his age would be much of a challenge for him. On top of that, if you go for the 'Jeff tried to kill him but Liu survived the damage!' approach:
I say OBJECTION! :iconobjectionplz:
Jeff does not seem to be the type of killer who would leave someone to die on their own; he's more of the 'finish them off' and 'it's more fun to actually kill them' type of serial killer. And even if in the very very very very unlikely scenario that he did leave Liu to die, he was using a full sized butcher knife from the kitchen, pretty big and sharp, easy to slice vital arteries and veins. Liu would have quickly died, and be, well, dead.

And even with the unbearable amount of flaws in Jeff's story (once again, that's why I pick on him so much) I doubt that Liu would have survived.

He is dead, or at least that is what Jeff's story's original writer(s) intended. Anything saying that he survived is most likely fanfic or OC based. I'm being as stubborn as Zehnder on this topic. The only thing that will change my mind is if there is a followup story to Jeff's proving that Liu is alive written by his original writers. And even then my headcanon would be that he is as dead as Scollex was near the end of Forgotten Past Part 1. And not in the way that he'll be back later, in the way as in dead means dead.

This being said Liu will NEVER appear in my art WITH THE EXCEPTION OF if he is a ghost, if it is a flashback or anything of that sort, or photographs or anything of that sort.

To me, Liu being alive at the end of Jeff's story is as likely as Zehnder, in that part of Sadist where Esther asked if she could stay with him (The day where they first actually talked, not the end), squeeing and then rapidly saying YES YES YES YES YES and then grabbing her hand and skipping like Pinkie Pie off into the sunset while making that squeaky bounce noise she makes.


 
And these analysis things are pretty damn fun, because I love thoroughly analyzing things (as long as they genuinely interest me) and then stating my opinion with plenty of facts and quotes to support my points. So I'll probably be doing much more. Like my thoughts on Hoody in Marble Hornets, had an interesting conversation with GummyDragon
If you have any suggestions on anything to make observations on then I'll consider it, not going to guarantee anything though. Also doesn't have to be only creepypasta, can be Silent hill, ponies, etc.

~~~

ああ~ おまえ 怒ってるだよ! ケケケ~!
© 2013 - 2024 Jinbeizamezama
Comments115
Join the community to add your comment. Already a deviant? Log In
Enigma1315's avatar
I have something you could think about. I can't remember if you've said something about this or not and I don't know if you'll actually do a little journal concerning this, but I've always wondered something about a slender's tendrils. Like, are they made up of energy or are a part of their body, like an arm. So, would it hurt them if someone tried to cut one off? It's just a thought...